Jack Nelligan
New member
Would it be possible for the mysterious daughter of Indy to have actually been the child of Indy and Willie Scott?
Crack that whip said:Honestly, when I first saw her in the show back in the day when it first aired, I was actually guessing she could be the daughter of Willie and Indy, but of course there's nothing to substantiate it.
Given how the series has evolved since, I doubt she is now. Even if she was intended to be at the time her appearances were shot and shown, I don't think there's any intention on Lucas/Lucasfilm's part now of her being Willie's daughter - indeed, with the removal of the bookends her whole "official" existence may be up in the air now, though I believe it's all still canon until some definitive word from Lucasfilm says otherwise.
nitzsche said:Could she not be Mutt's wife?
Lonsome_Drifter said:Er...They'd be half-brother and sister. That would be kinda nasty, don't you think?
IndyFan89 said:There will never be a Indy 5 for us to find out.
Attila the Professor said:I think he meant the mysterious daughter in the Old Indy bits from YIJC, not Indy and Willie's hypothetical spawn.
ha!! thats funny. no i think Willie was in ToD and meant to be only in ToD. she's just a part of Indy history now, and will never return...lost in the winds of time...lol.arkfinder said:Let me give the answer Luke gave Darth Vader in ESB when Vader told him he was his Father:
"Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!"
nitzsche said:Could she not be Mutt's wife?
Not if it takes place after "Skull"...(anyway, this thread is completely redundant).Jack Nelligan said:What if she is the product of Indy and Willie hooking up in Indy V? Wouldn?t that put her right about the correct age?
Stoo said:Not if it takes place after "Skull"...(anyway, this thread is completely redundant).
Jack Nelligan said:What if she is the product of Indy and Willie hooking up in Indy V? Wouldn’t that put her right about the correct age? I know Willie is older, but stranger things have happened.
Come on Stoo play along! Where do you think the daughter came from???
Robyn said:Come on now Jack, you know that's never gonna happen! It better not! If Steven and George shatter Indy and Marion's relationship and bring Willie back I will NEVER forgive them!
Jack Nelligan said:I think it would be Indy and Marion who shatter their relationship. Both have such strong personalities that I find it hard to see how they stay together.
Robyn said:Na! No way they'd break up now, after everything they've been through.