I beat it in 3 days without setting out to, so I guess I'll give my take. As I just stated, it's short. I was surprised to get through it so quickly, given that GTAIV and Red Dead took considerably longer, but there it is. The story, graphics, and motion capture are fantastic. The linearity of the game and clumsy mechanics of the vehicles, plus difficulty getting the interviews down, were highly frustrating. Would have been easier to forgive with some online play, but Rockstar decided against that for some odd reason. Yeah you spend a lot of down time searching for clues and interrogating witnesses/suspects, and rarely wield a gun (and then for only a few seconds at a time). It can seem a bit draggish at times, but it's worth all that for a new type of gaming experience. All in all, 3.5/5. Overall very enjoyable, but a bit of a letdown imo. One of its real strengths and innovations, I think the facial motion capture was also one of its limitations in that story length, linearity of the plot, and relatively few add-on options were kind of the result of having to carefully manage real-life acting resources.