Skywalker82
New member
I mean both SW prequels and Indy 4 are considered slap in faces to fans of both franchises and considered big mistakes by Lucas
AndyLGR said:I would rather watch the SW prequels over KOTCS.
I thought the story of KOTCS was awful and the characters with the exception of Indy were really bad. Mac, Ox, Mutt, Marion were terrible in the last half of the film. It was a mess. I watch the film and I can't believe they didn't stop to think that the last half is a total cluster**** and the ending made no sense with a pointless macguffin. Did they really wait so long to make that.Montana Smith said:KOTCS was that bad?
I thought the Prequels only began to feel like they belonged in the Star Wars universe towards the end of ROTS.
And the best bits of KOTCS were up until the end of the Doom Town sequence. Might as well sleep through the rest.
AndyLGR said:I thought the story of KOTCS was awful and the characters with the exception of Indy were really bad. Mac, Ox, Mutt, Marion were terrible in the last half of the film. It was a mess. I watch the film and I can't believe they didn't stop to think that the last half is a total cluster**** and the ending made no sense with a pointless macguffin. Did they really wait so long to make that.
I much prefer to watch the SW prequels over KOTCS depite all of the flaws that trilogy had. I can't think of a bigger film disappointment for me than KOTCS.
Skywalker82 said:Would you compare it to the SW prequels?
Montana Smith said:a big steaming turd lying in the middle of Indy's driveway preventing him from getting his car out
Randy_Flagg said:As bad as the prequels were, it still feels as if more effort went into making them. I don't like a lot of the decisions George made, but I can see the ambition is there.
KOTCS, on the other, kind of feels as if George and Steven were just goofing around and having a fun trip down memory lane, without really being too concerned about the end result.
Walecs said:I like all of them. Both SW prequels and KOTCS. Haters gonna hate!
I enjoy watching them, and there's nothing bad about it.
HovitosKing said:Based on the eloquent statements above, I have a feeling you fall into the demographic these films were meant to appeal to in the first place. It's therefore unsurprising that you liked them. That said, I hated them all equally. Cheers.
Montana Smith said:
As fast as they burn it, we can rebuild it by asserting our own version of the canon. Lucasian aberrations post-1989 may simply be dismissed as poor fan fiction.
Raiders112390 said:Did Uncle George rape your childhood?