I honestly for the life of me cant find fault with Shias acting? Its not that im a huge fan. I just dont see it. I personally think he does a great job. BUT then again some people think Tom Hanks is the best actor out there...I dont..Heck I dont even like Robert DeNiro outside of "meet the parent" movies..So not everyone sees the same things. I see Shia as just as good as any of the mentioned..Mickiana said:Shia's involvement with Indiana Jones: one movie too many. Not his fault though. Those responsible haven't helped him to become a competent actor, if indeed he is capable. He was miscast as Indiana Jones' son. That's it for him in the indyverse.
mikieson said:I honestly for the life of me cant find fault with Shias acting? Its not that im a huge fan. I just dont see it. I personally think he does a great job. BUT then again some people think Tom Hanks is the best actor out there...I dont..Heck I dont even like Robert DeNiro outside of "meet the parent" movies..So not everyone sees the same things. I see Shia as just as good as any of the mentioned..
emtiem said:'Indy's son' could have been a disaster
Montana Smith said:Indy's son was a disaster!
Shia is just Shia.
By the same token Harrison is just Harrison. Except he has some charisma. (Unless he's playing himself, in which case he's exceedingly dull and often bordering on catatonic).
Olliana said:And people thinking Harrison is just himself in his movies is what makes him such a great actor. Because it is NOT easy to make it look like that.
I see a very different HF in all his movies. THe 2 that are similar in ways to me would be Han and Indy..other than that he does pretty good and bringing something new each time. Good actor. Probably one of the all time best actually...and I dont even like all his movies. I just know good talent when I see it.Montana Smith said:Harrison is a one-trick pony. But it's a very good trick.
Montana Smith said:Indy's son was a disaster!
Marshall2288 said:This probably won't win over any popularity votes for me but I think Eric Bana, Clive Owen if he can do an American accent or even Adrian Brody (after seeing that he CAN be cool in Predators) could do a pretty good Indy.
replican't said:How about someone who doesnt look anything like Harrison Ford?
You want to reboot, reboot properly, like they do with Bond or Dr Who. Bring something new to the table.
replican't said:How about someone who doesnt look anything like Harrison Ford?
You want to reboot, reboot properly, like they do with Bond or Dr Who. Bring something new to the table.
Marshall2288 said:Yea I agree that they don't need to look like Harrison. Anyone with a close enough body shape can pull off the Indy shadow and look just like the real deal. I look at the Star Trek reboot. The new characters are similar in looks and style but it's a clean palate. I love Indiana Jones, not Harrison Ford. If an actor can pull off the spirit of him and nore importantly the story is right, I'm game for a reboot.
replican't said:You want to reboot, reboot properly, like they do with Bond or Dr Who. Bring something new to the table.
Archaeos said:You mean like casting Alan Cumming as the new Indy?
Attila the Professor said:If Jeremy Renner were a couple years younger, he'd be a potentially compelling choice.