Originally Posted by Goodeknight
Here's one inspired by a recent thread...
River Phoenix vs. Sean Patrick Flannery
(I think it's a pretty easy one, but I'm putting it out there anyway.)
Probably Flannery. After all, his version of Indy actually participated in WWI, not to mention knew some martial arts in Treasure of the Peacock's Eye. Phoenix's Indy was still new to the gig.