Ford - Better as Indy or Han?

Some of you must have an opinion on whether Ford was better at being Han Solo or Indiana Jones??

And why you think so!

[Aaron H]

Hmmm, I would have to say he is better as Jones. Just because he doesn't change throughout the movies like in Star Wars. (But he does a great job as Han in The Empire Srikes Back)

[Col. Musgrove]

He's no doubt better known as Han. I think he does better at Jones. You have to admit, if he were asked now to reprise Han Solo, he'd say no, but he'd be more willing to be Jones.

You're right about that.

[Indy Canuck]

I guess it all comes down to which one is your favourite character. Are you a SW or an Indy fanatic?

Ford is best recognized as Jones, and is probably the best role of his career. IMHO he was better at Jones. Although Solo was the tough, cool rogue character in the first SW film, realistically anyone could have pulled that one off, but from the start, Ford made Indy HIS character.

They're both great in my book, though.

If you ask me, any role Ford would do he would, with all his effort, give justice to the role... in the first place John Travolta was the first choice for Han Solo and Tom Seleck (is my spelling right?)is the first choice for Indy.


Robert

[VP]

Indy.

[Webley]

Indy all the way!
Now what if Dr. Jones and Mr Solo came to blows. I bet if it was whith guns Han would blast Indy away but thats gest caus I think Han is a better shot. If it was man to man no guns or anything Jones would punch the crap out of that space jocky and let him cry for his mommy.

[fatima]

Originally posted by Webley

If it was man to man no guns or anything Jones would punch the crap out of that space jocky and let him cry for his mommy.

LOL I agree!
My answer goes to Indy, is much more complex than Solo, has a bigger charisma and thrilles me much more than Han.

[00Kevin]

Bob Falfa




Indy, hands down!

[intergamer]

Indy is Harrison's character - he shaped it, made Indy like himself; Han is more George Lucas' character.

Also, Indy is more developed than Han - since there are three movies exclusively about Indy.

Does Harrison act better in Star Wars or Indiana Jones? I'd say its a tossup. But the Indy character is better, and definitely a better vehicle for Harrison.

[Edited by intergamer on 11-17-2003 at 03:49 pm]

[Winston]

intergamer, I could not agree more with what you just said.
And yes, I think Ford does act better as Indy. If you can call it acting, the indy films seem more like documentories on a day in the life of Harrison Ford. Ford IS Indy!

[jamie]

Indy by far. Indy has much more character and charisma then Han and his character is much more developed. But thats only natural since Han wasnt even the main character in Star Wars.

While we're on the topic, in Temple Of Doom when Indy chases a couple of Thugee guards, only run into a large group of them and is chased back, do you think this was an homage to Star Wars when the exact same thing happens to han after he chases some Stormtroopers?

Jim

[Winston]

Yes

[intergamer]

hmm, thats interesting: i saw star wars first, and when I saw the ToD scene it looked familiar, but i never could figure out where I saw it before.

[Pootie Tang]

I hated Star Wars and like the Indiana Jones series....you know what my ****ing answer is

[Aaron H]

Pootie Tang, please watch your language.

[westford]

Don't make me choose!!!

I prefer the Indy films to the Star Wars films, but I think I maybe like Solo's character more than Jones... Only very slightly though. There are moments when the two overlap, in spite of all the attempts to keep the two characters completely different, so could I have a bit of both please?

[QueZTone]

for me it depends on which movie i saw last

currently its Indy

[Katarn07]

Harrison Ford is so well known as the man in the hat, despite me liking Star Wars over Indy, I still know Ford as that relic hunter as do most people I know. Do you think he'd be as well known had he not played the part of Indy? I highly doubt it but you never know....

Anyhow, he was great in ANH and ESB as Solo, but something seemed amiss in RotJ. I like RotJ for Luke whereas I watch the other two for Han. He's great in all three Indy movies though and my vote is for Indy

Also I noticed that scene in ToD when he runs into all the Thugees and Han had run into all the Stormies. I pointed it out to my dad who had just noticed how he was just going to blow the Thugees away as he does the Cairo Swordsman. That's two "easter eggs", if you can really call them that, in the same scene. One of the best in the trilogy.

[Edited by Matthias1138 on 11-19-2003 at 03:05 pm]

[grumpus]

im not sure what he is better in, but iwas comparing the raven to a starwars forum, everyone here knows what they are talking about, they dont know anything.

[Aaron H]

Originally posted by Renderking Fisk

I had to leave the forum at TheForce.Net because of that reason and it became TOO political. It’s not even a STAR WARS forum anymore… it’s a platform for the far FAR Left agenda with some Spoiler-rants. There are some leftists here, but not nearly to the extent of TheForce.Net.

We have some heated debates here, but the mods reign in the political hot-talk. TheForce.Net is a perfect example of why.

As long as I am a mod here, I will never let the Raven become like the Jedi Coucil.

Now...back to the topic "Ford - Better as Indy or Han?"

[intergamer]

yes, i've noticed that people here read the previous posts before posting (although at tFn the problem may be that there are too many posts)

sorry, offtopic

-itrae
negmr