Innis said:
there are certain other factors that led to the demise on the first line (it has nothing to do with poor sales)
I feel the problems with Kenner's The Adventures of Indiana Jones line had nothing to do with the popularity of the movie.
The biggest problem was they
severely underproduced Indiana Jones. The main character of the movie and toy line was literally nowhere to be found. I remember digging through stacks and stacks of Toht and the Cairo swordsman trying to find Indy and Marion.
I also think the line would have been better served if Kenner had not waited for a year after the movie before releasing their first Indy figures.
The failure of that line was more Kenner's fault than anything.
LJN's Temple of Doom line didn't even have a chance. The media and parents groups whipped themselves into hysterics about the over hyped violence in the movie. Which is actually tame by today's standards. Episode 3 was a lot more violent than Doom. Parents getting upset over violence in the Indy movies really isn't a problem anymore.
I really like the Disney figures. But in all honesty, their sculpts and paint jobs weren't the greatest by any means. That put off a lot of people and had to have hurt the sales. Not to mention the high prices for quality of the figures and they were only available at the Disney parks.
I feel Hasbro would be making a mistake releasing Indy Unleashed figures. Indy doesn't really fit in the extreme and exaggerated Unleashed style and a line of well sculpted Indiana Jones Trilogy figures made in the 3 3/4 inch classic SW and Indy scale are long overdue.
If they wanted to test the market, I think it would be better if they released a small assortment of Indiana Jones figures in the SW vintage original trilogy collection style. An updated 3 3/4 inch Indy figure on a retro style card would be a much better fit for the property than a large plastic grimacing statue in an extreme pose.
I understand and agree with the argument that Indy is not as popular as SW. But in all honestly and fairness not much can come close to competing with SW in popularity. I also don't think Indy would take in SW type sales and really not much does. But it would still sell and sell well.