I love ToD. It was the first Indy movie I ever saw at the impressionable age of 8. To this day it is my favorite of the bunch, and will probably remain my favorite. But I can see why people are divided on this movie. It does posses a different tone in comparison with Raiders. It is darker and more violent, but at the same time it is also funnier in some aspects, even if the humor was darker and more aimed at gross-out humor. The film is also a lot more spontaneous then the other 3 in terms of set-up. All the other ones have a more traditional set-up while ToD Indy is just thrown into it the action as soon as the movie starts. A couple of the things I really do love about the movie are the sets (the mines, mine-cart chase, rope bridge in particular.) and how Indy is more of a mercenary in this movie but also still feels like the same character from Raiders. And the character Short Round was also rather enjoyable and is my favorite Indy side-kick (I wouldn't classify Sallah or Henry Jones Sr. as side-kicks). I'll watch the movie any time!