Alright, just finished the PS2 version.
Went back and played some levels that I found somewhat enjoyable. Anyway I'm disappointed overall with the game. The premise is some parts were so cool (last level) but executed so poorly.
The graphics look nice on a basic tube television, but pretty bland, blurry, and muddy an a plasma HDTV. There's so many little glitches during this game like missing sound effects, jiggling polys and textures, and a VERY poorly executed story. Plus I hate the fact that when you have an enemy in a grapple and you're going to deliver the last punch, they fall before you make contact. Ugh. And in the last level, study the water in the cutscenes. Seriously, go ahead. It's laughable. One polygon is a wave. I can't believe they shipped the game with that in it.
What just happened? What did I just play? The staff of moses is a brilliant artifact for Indy to go after but the game delivered that so poorly. I could give two sh1ts about any characters in the game also. The only way it takes place in 1939 is by the game telling you. Why couldn't they have Marcus or Sallah or ANYONE appear? A mention by Indy would've even sufficed. In fact, there's no mention of anything previous to Indy's adventures besides the music.
The levels stink in the beginning, they get better in the middle (Nepal is the best level IMO), and then they stink in the end. And the PS2 is a rip off. You could unlock movie trailers to all 4 films, some concept art, or play the same crappy game over again with some new skins. And that's it. Lame. They made this game look so great. Let me tell ya, the marketing guys at LucasArts should get a raise AND castrations.
I would sell my copy now if I wasn't such an Indy whore. Man, what a missed opportunity. And while playing the last level all I could think is how amazing it would look on next gen consoles. What a shame. Hopefully the DS version is better.
Rent it if you're a HUGE Indy fan. Other then that skip it.
In the words of Indy: Trust me.
Anyway I give it a 2.5/5 (and I'm being generous)
Thank god Ghostbusters is coming out next week.