Wow, that's really grown up of you guys.... Name calling! NOW you're getting somewhere.
I challenge you, when Hollywood Homicide comes out on video. Rent/buy it, watch Last Crusade. Or any of the Indy films. Then watch Hollywood Homicide. THEN tell me he did just as good a job in HH as he has with Indy.
If you'll re-read my above post, you'll also notice that I said, at parts he seemed tired, and not into it. Other parts (like the last 20 min.) he was very into it, and did a great job. That part was much more his style than the rest of the film.
I really like HF, and think he's a pretty good actor. But if he's the greatest, where are his Oscars? He's only even been nominated once. Now that's okay with me, I'd still rather have him as Indy than anyone else. I think there's something more personable about his acting than many of the 'greats.'
I appreciate the flaming, keep up the high-maturity level that's been maintained in this thread.