EDIT: Mods, I accidentally posted this in the Indy Trilogy forum. Is it possible you could move it to General Indy Discussion? Thanks a lot!
I remember reading in Lawrence Kasdan's Raiders of the Lost Ark revised third-draft script this particular passage:
Indy's line "I've already served" also made it into the novelization.
Now, this script snippet is interesting to me because it suggests that, at the time of Raiders, Lucas and Spielberg were imagining that Indy served as a "doughboy" in the American Army during World War I. Of course, that line never made it into the film, and so Lucas much later decided to have Indy join the Belgian Army in the Young Indy Chronicles.
It's fascinating to see this glimpse of an alternate character history for Indy that might have been. Another very interesting "road not taken" was the early idea from George Lucas' initial Raiders script treatment that our beloved Dr. Jones should a high-living, nightclub-going playboy with a Manhattan penthouse.
Also, Kasdan's Indy seems to be relatively poor with languages. This is hinted at in Raiders by his failure to speak Hovitos, and his use of a local Imam to translate the Staff of Ra headpiece. Of course, the Indy of later films and Young Indy is fluent in dozens of tongues.
This last point is perhaps best demonstrated by Sean Patrick Flanery's Indy, who (I think it was in Treasure of the Peacock's Eye) flirts with a girl while changing his language with every sentence. Again, note how Young Indy differs from Raiders in presenting a more competent, worldly Indy.
So, what abandoned aspects of Indy's character do you find most fascinating or compelling? What "lost" character traits would you like to revisit?
I remember reading in Lawrence Kasdan's Raiders of the Lost Ark revised third-draft script this particular passage:
Raiders said:
Indy's line "I've already served" also made it into the novelization.
Now, this script snippet is interesting to me because it suggests that, at the time of Raiders, Lucas and Spielberg were imagining that Indy served as a "doughboy" in the American Army during World War I. Of course, that line never made it into the film, and so Lucas much later decided to have Indy join the Belgian Army in the Young Indy Chronicles.
It's fascinating to see this glimpse of an alternate character history for Indy that might have been. Another very interesting "road not taken" was the early idea from George Lucas' initial Raiders script treatment that our beloved Dr. Jones should a high-living, nightclub-going playboy with a Manhattan penthouse.
Story treatment for Raiders by George Lucas said:
Also, Kasdan's Indy seems to be relatively poor with languages. This is hinted at in Raiders by his failure to speak Hovitos, and his use of a local Imam to translate the Staff of Ra headpiece. Of course, the Indy of later films and Young Indy is fluent in dozens of tongues.
This last point is perhaps best demonstrated by Sean Patrick Flanery's Indy, who (I think it was in Treasure of the Peacock's Eye) flirts with a girl while changing his language with every sentence. Again, note how Young Indy differs from Raiders in presenting a more competent, worldly Indy.
So, what abandoned aspects of Indy's character do you find most fascinating or compelling? What "lost" character traits would you like to revisit?
Last edited:
