Journey to Mecca

Le Saboteur

Active member
Knowledge brings a great reward. The one who points the way to something good is like the one who does it. When the knowledgeable person dies, his reward with Allah does not cease when he dies, rather it continues to increase so long as people benefit from his knowledge. The Prophet (may Allah exalt his mention) said: "When a man dies, all his deeds come to an end except for three — an ongoing charity, beneficial knowledge or a righteous child who will pray for him.

In 2007 while the Family Jones was lounging around <del>Hawaii</del>... er, Peru and the Family O'Connell was barnstorming around China, a crew from National Geographic was in the deserts of Morocco attempting to bring one of Islam's holiest sites, the Kaaba, to life for the purpose of bringing the 14th Century Hajj to the silver screen.

The end result of their effort was Journey to Mecca: In the Footsteps of Ibn Battuta, a 45-minute docu-drama on perhaps the world's greatest traveler, Ibn Battuta.


Unfortunately the film's length allows the viewer only a brief look into who Ibn Battuta was and who he came to be.

When he undertook his travels, Ibn Battuta was a 21-year old law student. Inspired by a dream to undertake the Hajj, he left his home of Tangier in northern Morocco in 1325. A journey of some 3-thousand miles, it would take him from Morocco to Cairo, the Mother of the World, Jerusalem, Aleppo and Damascus before finally to Mecca some three years later. While traveling he documented much of what he saw in his diary; a lawyer, theologian, and poet his accounts of the medieval Eastern world are often our only primary source.

He would eventually make seven pilgrimages to the Holy City over his lifetime, but his travels would take him to Spain, Turkey, Persia, Russia, and the assorted Arab lands. Following a three year stay in Mecca after his second pilgrimage, Battuta turned his attention to the Far East. After touring through Syria and Egypt he found himself in the court of the Sultan of Delhi. After being accepted into the Sultan’s entourage, he would spend eight years as a qadi, a local judge, before being sent to China to act as the Sultan’s ambassador.

That journey would make even the most two-fisted adventurer green with envy. As soon as he departed Delhi, he would be captured by bandits and marked for death if one of their band hadn’t taken pity on him and allowed Battuta to escape in the night. Following an eight day manhunt, he would finally rejoin his entourage in Calicut, a trading port near India’s tip. Weather would become his enemy here as the junk loaded with gifts for the Chinese court was smashed against the shoals during a storm, and the smaller vessel made off with his few personal belongings in the confusion.

Ibn Battuta would eventually make to China following a stint in the Maldives, becoming the first person in history to record those islands' histories and customs. Upon his eventual return to Tangier 24-years later he would become the most celebrated traveler in the world outdoing both Marco Polo and Columbus. Not until the Age of Steam would his feats be equaled.

Do check out his Rihla (Travels) available at finer booksellers everywhere. The University of California at Berkeley also has fine repository of his journey available on-line.

Now back to the movie.

It's a sumptuously filmed piece; the reported $13-million went to good use in recreating the 14th Century world. The costumes are superb, as are the locations. There's even a sandstorm to rival anything Hidalgo could digitally conjure. They've also assembled the largest caravan ever to be caught on film for Ibn Battuta's first pilgrimage to Mecca. It's even bigger than the one in Lawrence of Arabia! According to the producers, it features 500 people in period costume, 330 camels (Watch out! They spit.), and 660 donkeys, sheep, and goats.

Bookending Battuta’s first trip are scenes from 2007’s Hajj. Hajjis arrive at Islam’s holiest city via car, plane, and boat. From all walks of life they venture to Mecca in order to reaffirm their faith, and to deepen their sense of ‘oneness’, or tawheed. Despite their social and economic background, it is all set aside during the 5-days of the Hajj to remind them that “we’re all one before God.”

For outsiders, this might be where the movie shines. It takes a concept, the Hajj, and breaks into down into what happens on what day and the significance behind it. It has my endorsement just for this aspect.

4268_2.jpg


Dig that image quality. IMAX features usually lose something when being transferred to home video, but this one stands out. The aerial photography is nothing short of stunning, and the details are vividly clear. Do yourself a favor and pick it up on Blu-ray.

But if you're a cheap or lazy bastard, it is available on the 'net. Sam Earch could help you find it if you're so inclined.

Background reading:

Mecca Development Veers to Kitsch

In Mecca, a Hotel Boom

The late Sheikh Hamza Shakkur and his Al Kindi Ensemble provide a significant portion of the soundtrack.


Finally, the movie's original site has a lot of other videos and other background material.

Journey to Mecca Giant Screen
 
Last edited:

Stoo

Well-known member
Le Saboteur said:
That journey would make even the most two-fisted adventurer green with envy. As soon as he departed Delhi, he would be captured by bandits and marked for death if one of their band hadn?t taken pity on him and allowed Battuta to escape in the night. Following an eight day manhunt, he would finally rejoin his entourage in Calicut, a trading port near India?s tip.
As exciting as the guy's adventures may have been, this film seems to have a distinct odour of Islamic propaganda.
Le Saboteur said:
They've also assembled the largest caravan ever to be caught on film for Ibn Battuta's first pilgrimage to Mecca. It's even bigger than the one in Lawrence of Arabia! According to the producers, it features 500 people in period costume, 330 camels (Watch out! They spit.), and 660 donkeys, sheep, and goats.
Those numbers of the 'largest-caravan-on-film' are highly questionable (despite what the 'producers' say).
Le Saboteur said:
But if you're a cheap or lazy bastard, it is available on the 'net.
From the voice of the wise to the mouths of babes, take heed to Le Saboteur, y'all!;)
 

Le Saboteur

Active member
Stoo said:
As exciting as the guy's adventures may have been, this film seems to have a distinct odour of Islamic propaganda.

Your comment, Stoo, is so freighted with unpleasant implications that it doesn't merit a proper response. I am disheartened that you would forward the knuckle dragger's argument nonetheless.
 

Stoo

Well-known member
Yes, I'm sorry to have written that. If it makes you feel any better, I would've said the same thing about Christian propaganda had the film been about a pilgrimage to see a bleeding or crying statue of Jesus.

That said, I will watch this movie. It looks good!:)
 

Mickiana

Well-known member
"freighted" - I have never seen it used like this. A "comment that is freighted with..."! I like it. Movie looks good too.
 

Le Saboteur

Active member
Le Saboteur said:
Bookending Battuta?s first trip are scenes from 2007?s Hajj. Hajjis arrive at Islam?s holiest city via car, plane, and boat. From all walks of life they venture to Mecca in order to reaffirm their faith, and to deepen their sense of ?oneness?, or tawheed. Despite their social and economic background, it is all set aside during the 5-days of the Hajj to remind them that ?we?re all one before God.?

Fun Fact: At current rates it will take the average Muslim 500-years before before they'll be allowed to visit Mecca.

The logistics the Al Sauds undertake to accommodate the million plus pilgrims is astounding. But with all of the luxury hotels springing up around the Grand Mosque how serious of a pilgrimage is it going to be? How is everybody going to continue to be one before God when a sizable chunk will be cloistered in air conditioning while the poors sweat their sock off in tents? Is Mecca starting to resemble a version of Disneyland?

For anybody who pays attention to world events, one will notice dueling propositions for what Mecca is becoming and how it should be.

Basma Atassi said:
Sami Angawi refuses to call Mecca a city, for his Mecca could never be transformed into a metropolis - no matter how deep the drills dig or how fierce the battle between the skyscrapers and the clouds.

Mecca is a ?sanctuary,? he says. ?It?s God?s house, the refuge of humans, the birthplace of Islam.? It is the sanctuary established by the archetype of the perfect Muslim, Prophet Abraham, he adds.

Basma Atassi said:
In 2006, the architect stirred debate when he told a regional television channel that where once there had been historical sites - the Prophet Muhammad?s house and the oldest school of Islam, Dar al-Arkam - there were now roads and public facilities. ?These places have always been known to the Meccans,? he says, adding: ?And now I am trying to use old and modern maps to scientifically locate these historical sites.?

Basma Atassi said:
Since the 1980s, more than 95 percent of Mecca?s historical sites - many dating back to the earliest years of Islam in the seventh century - have been demolished, making way for towers and five-star hotels. Then, of course, there is the Mecca Clock Tower, which is 46 times taller than the nearby al-Kaaba, the black cubical considered to be the holiest structure in Islam and around which Muslims circumambulate to signify harmony in the worship of God. The result is stark.

Basma Atassi said:
But not all ideas can be ?implemented realistically,? Achmed Rasch, the son of Mahmoud, told me as we sat in a cafe in the Fairmont Hotel, located in the clock tower complex. The 35-year-old managing director of Vista Rasch GmbH, a company that specialises in films and exhibition projects in the holy cities, is now overseeing the launch of an observatory and an astronomy exhibition centre built in the enclosure of the clock.

The younger Rasch says building hotels away from the centre would increase traffic on the roads leading to the mosque. He also cites the mountainous nature of Mecca as an obstruction to what might otherwise look like a good option on paper.

He suggests that the best way to preserve the history of Mecca and to make it accessible to millions of visitors would be to set up a museum. ?And we are working on such concepts,? he adds.

Full article: The Man Who Dreams of Old Mecca

If for nothing more, then stop in and check out the pictures of Angawi's very impressive home!

tumblr_me7pl7FmcL1rhfx4eo1_500.jpg
 

Joe Brody

Well-known member
Le Saboteur said:
Is Mecca starting to resemble a version of Disneyland?


I don't worry about it. When you drive in and out of MCO, you don't have to drive past light armor emplacements with 50 cals like you do at Jeddah (which is as near to Mecca as I'll ever get). And at the rate things are going in the Kingdom (the KAS that is), it won't be anything like a Disney World any time in this era.


Also, this is worthwhile reading:

http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2012/04/16/modern-mecca
 
Top