I've not properly played video games for decades, so am very much out of the loop in terms of what's considered good and popular etc, but I do think this looks terrific - the characters and locations look incredibly well realised and the story is intriguing. It might not be enough to tempt me to get an X Box (though never say never!), but it's great to see an Indy game so close to being photo-realisitc - the technology has come on so much since the brilliant Emperor's Tomb (well, I guess Staff of Kings is most recent but that felt like a step backwards in every way!)! The story does seem more intriguing than perhaps either of the most recent cinema outings, and this might be the closest thing we ever get to another Indy movie, although...
One think I noticed is that the look and voice of Indy does seem to be a sort of interpretation of Ford's performance rather than a direct impersonation. I imagine the technology exists to make the character look a lot more like Ford if they want, and certainly the voice in Emperor's Tomb felt closer to his. I'm wondering if this is deliberate, and they're trying to subtly move the character away from Ford, sort of testing the water for a recast at some point down the line...