SATC made mad money because it was the first chick-flic to come out in months + it had a built in audience & a huge promotional campaign. But it did squat compared to Indy's opening weekend take! And Indy almost made as much its second weekend - after raking in even more money Tues-Thurs. I'm not sure what people are squawking about.
The numbers tell me nothing. The Wizard of Oz was a B.O. disappointment, but is a beloved classic now. Ditto other fantasy films like The Dark Crystal, Willow, Labyrinth, The Thief of Bagdad, Greystoke The Legend of Tarzan, Pinnochio etc. Numbers don't 'mean' anything.
In ten years, if people are still enjoying KOtCS, then it will have won its' place in the series. I just watched The Phantom Menace with a couple of kids last week, and after almost a decade, the movie still stands up, and it got torn apart critically. We watched The Secret of NIMH too - that was a B.O. 'disappointment' and got mixed reviews as well. But kids still love it & it's turned out to be an animation classic.
Screw the 'numbers'!
When did movie fans turn into a bunch of bean counters, pitting movies against each other like race horses? Pathetic.